Amy Adams in W Magazine

Posted on Apr 15, 2009 in Fashion

The It Girl of the moment, Amy Adams, is featured on the cover and accompanying editorial of W Magazine.

Marc Jacobs Spring 2009 Collection
Model: Anastasija Kondratjeva

We’re in disagreement on this one. Lorenzo thinks she looks great but Tom thinks she’s playing against type and not doing such a great job of it. We’re in agreement that it’s a fine idea to make her up in an image that you wouldn’t expect for her; it’s just that one of us thinks she succeeded and the other one doesn’t. Tom thinks that, for the cover shot, they should have interpreted the clothes a little better, rather than simply take the entire look directly from the runway and put it on her back. Lorenzo, in a fit of gay prissiness, hates the dark nail polish on her.

Michael Kors Spring 2009 Collection
Model: Coco Rocha

Topshop’s black and white cotton jacket, Michael Kors’s black and white cotton and silk dress

Marc Jacobs’s yellow cotton voile top, Levi’s Capital E blue cotton and elastane jeans

It’s the whole retro/heavy eyeliner/bad girl thing that grates for Tom. It just doesn’t feel like her and she doesn’t look particularly comfortable selling it. Granted, she’s done a lot of the expected Good Girl imagery up to this point and we both agree that something new was needed. We’re just not in agreement as to whether this was the way to go.

What say you, ladies?

Photographed by Craig McDean
Styled by Alex White

[Photos: Craig McDean/wmagazine.com/style.com]